Image Source: iStock
Both puff pastry and phyllo dough are used to make baked items, including everything from sweet desserts to savory tarts and pastries. Although they serve a similar purpose, they are not the same. In this article, we will discuss puff pastry vs. filo pastry.
We will help you figure out each pastry’s purpose, which you should choose, and which pastry is suitable for a specific dish.
Table of Contents
What is Puff Pastry?
Puff pastry, also known as pâte feuilletée in French, is produced by rolling out pastry, inserting a cube of butter, folding the dough, rolling it out again, then folding it once more to create contrasting layers (and layers) of dough and butter.
Although the layers of the dough are not particularly visible as it is being formed, when it is baked, those folds result in distinct, airy, flaky layers and a crispy finish.
In Spite of the fact, you can create puff pastry from scratch, many chefs prefer to use frozen puff (check the label to make sure it’s produced from butter only and not another fat). Both sweet and savory dishes—from breakfast to dinner—can be made with puff pastry, from tarts to cookies.
What Exactly Is Phyllo Dough?
Phyllo dough, also referred to as filo dough, is a paper-thin pastry dough created by rolling together layers of dough. It bakes to become flaky and incredibly crunchy. Although the dough is thought to have originated in Turkey, where it is known as your ka, the Greek name filo (which means “leaf”) became widely used.
Most modern phyllo dough producers prepare the dough by machine and sell it frozen. Traditionally, bakers would roll out the pastry dough by hand using a long rolling pin called an oklava.
Difference Between Puff Pastry and Phyllo Dough
Although phyllo and puff pastry are regarded as pastries, their physical distinctions set them apart. When puff pastry is baked, it swells and seems thicker, and the unbaked dough is much more substantial than phyllo. Phyllo, on the other hand, is extremely thin before and after baking and translates to the Greek word for leaf.
Phyllo begins to resemble puff pastry when it is cooked in the conventional way. In this procedure, layers of the individual sheets are made on top of each other with butter in between, then baked until golden and flaky.
There are more subtle distinctions between these two adaptable pastry doughs than just the fact that one is French and the other is popular in the Balkans and the Middle East.
Puff pastry and phyllo are not interchangeable, even though both have several layers (unlike the classic pâté brisée we utilize in many recipes).
When comparing the two, puff pastry would appear considerably thicker and more resembling traditional pastry dough, whereas phyllo would resemble a sheaf of tissue paper.
If you substitute one for the other, your baked items can turn out differently than you had anticipated.
Puff Pastry vs. Phyllo Dough: Which to choose
It is a common question that comes to mind when choosing between both of the pastries for baking. You must know the difference between both of them so you can better decide which one you should use in your recipe. As we know, every recipe is different, so filo and puff pastries are also different in texture.
Puff pastry and phyllo pastry are two types of pastries that are both used for the same purpose. When you need to select between both pastries, you must keep in mind the nature of the dish you are making.
However, puff pastry is light in weight with buttery and flaky layers. Intensive rolling and folding have been done; each fold is covered with a layer of butter and fat. A Lot of effort is made while making puff pastry.
Furthermore, puff pastry is ideal for dishes in which flaky and delicate texture is required. The most commonly used recipes with puff pastries are croissants, turnovers, palmiers, and various sweet and savory pastries.
On the other hand, phyllo dough, also known as filo pastry, is very thin and unleavened with paper sheets. It is also created by layering these thin sheets with butter and oil.
Phyllo dough is perfect for dishes that require extra thin layers. Some of the recipes in which phyllo dough is used are baklava, spanakopita, and various Middle Eastern and Mediterranean pastries.
Pie Crust vs. Puff Pastry
Puff pastry and pie crust are made with the same ingredients, i.e., flour, water, and oil. Puff pastry is stretched out into paper-thin sheets and used for savory pastries, including quiches, tarts, croissants, and turnovers.
On the other hand, the pie crust is made into a thicker crust and is used for sweet pies, including fruit pies, custard pies, and meringue pies.
Which one is more tricky to make?
Both of the pastries require a good amount of effort to make. Although pie crust requires more work than puff pastry, it is significantly simpler to produce than pie crust.
The fundamental cause is that pie crust requires a lot of practice to perfect, but puff pastry requires less expertise to roll out.
Secondly, Pie crust is more difficult to produce than puff pastry because of the type of fat used.
While pie crust recipes frequently include lard or vegetable oil, puff pastry recipes frequently call for butter.
Due to the fact that lard has a higher melting point, it is more difficult to handle than butter. This thing makes it challenging to make pie crust.
Substitute for Puff Pastry
You can substitute a number of ingredients to give your meal the same flakiness and height as the original. When choosing a substitution, take in mind the specifications of your recipe because each substitute has a unique combination of advantages and disadvantages.
You can make a pie crust, strudel crust, or tart shell using Phyllo dough instead of regular pie crusts, strudel dough, or tart shells. Making layered biscuits successfully requires careful handling of the dough.
Furthermore, With biscuit dough, tarts and pot pies can be baked, or pastry can be formed with flaky dough by topping it with biscuit dough. It’s recommended to use pie crust, either homemade or manufactured, in place of puff pastry.
Is Phyllo Dough the Same as Puff Pastry?
he texture of filo dough is more crispier than that of puff pastry.
Although the two products’ thickness and composition are entirely different, phyllo dough functions well instead of puff pastry.
The ingredients for phyllo sheets include flour, oil, and water, which are quite thin. After each layer, you must brush a sizable amount of butter onto it.
Best store-bought puff pastry
Finding the best store-bought puff pastry for your favorite recipe is sometimes challenging. However, Dufour and Pepperidge Farms make the top puff pastry doughs available in stores. When it comes to pasty dough, these two compete most frequently.
In the US, both are commonly accessible. However, specific shops charge extra for Dufour.
Pepperidge Farm, which is prepared with shortening, has a little better texture and flavor than Dufour, which is made entirely with butter.
DuFour is superior, but Pepperidge Farm is more practical because it is more reasonably priced and of equal quality.
Final Thoughts
Above, we have discussed both of the pastries, and it is easier for us now to decide which pastry we should use.
Both fillo and puff pastries are used for baking, and sometimes, with special instruction, you can interchange both pastries in your recipes.
But remember that their texture is different, so if you are going to bake croissants or turnovers, puff pastry would be the ideal choice!
Happy baking!
Wondering about other breakfast choices? See if a toasted bagel with cream cheese is healthy
